We reviewed the 19 studies listed in Table 1 of Koch’s draft scoping review, using independent Astra and Opus 5.5 extractions followed by reconciliation against the papers. Uncertain findings were retained with caveats; results without supportable timing or outcome counts were not assigned a position on the graph. See the full spreadsheet for the evidence and source citations, and the key below to read the graph.
Settings
Key
Hours from TQ application to reported de-escalation/release. P = another or unclear endpoint (for example, hospital arrival), not confirmed release time.
- Click/tap: summary + paper.
- Double-click or Full details: full evidence.
Symbols & ranges
Dashed outline: positive cases reported; remaining outcome status / assessed denominator uncertain. No proportion implied.
Capsule length = reported range. Fill and fraction = positive / outcome-assessed; empty = supported negatives. Whole-group counts, not event positions.
These shapes identify kidney/muscle findings. In every lane, filled = positive; outlined = supported negative.
Kidney / Muscle Breakdown symbols
Positive/negative is finding-specific. Unreported outcomes are not inferred. Categories, not a severity scale.